Clubhouse #21 | Caffeine Timing, Dosing, and Genetic Response in Endurance Performance ☕

Caffeine is one of the most rigorously studied and widely used ergogenic aids in the world. Its ability to improve physical performance, mental alertness, and endurance output has made it a staple in both elite and recreational athletic contexts. But while the basic idea—“caffeine boosts performance”—is well known, the nuances that determine how effective caffeine is are rarely explored in depth.

Athletes often fail to consider how timing, dosing, and individual genetic variability can shape caffeine’s impact. Emerging research shows that the same caffeine protocol that enhances one runner’s performance might impair another’s. The key difference? A liver enzyme coded by the CYP1A2 gene.

In this week’s Clubhouse, we break down the physiology of how caffeine affects endurance performance, uncover why your genes matter, and outline the optimal caffeine strategies based on current scientific consensus—so you can maximize the benefit while avoiding tolerance, side effects, or performance crashes.

The Physiology of Caffeine: Why It Works for Endurance Athletes

Caffeine is a central nervous system stimulant that exerts its performance-enhancing effects primarily by blocking adenosine receptors in the brain. Adenosine is a neuromodulator that builds up during prolonged wakefulness and physical exertion, promoting relaxation, fatigue, and eventually sleep. By antagonizing these receptors, caffeine reduces perceived exertion, increases arousal, and improves motor unit recruitment—all critical variables in endurance contexts.

However, caffeine does more than just alter perception. It has been shown to increase the availability of circulating catecholamines like adrenaline and noradrenaline, enhance fat oxidation, and even improve calcium ion release in muscle tissue, improving contractile strength and endurance. These mechanisms combine to produce improvements in time to exhaustion, power output, sprint capacity at the end of long efforts, and cognitive performance under fatigue.

Numerous meta-analyses confirm that caffeine improves endurance performance by approximately 2–4% in trained individuals when used appropriately. But what defines “appropriate” can vary greatly depending on the individual.

Do you know where your tea comes from?

As global matcha supplies tighten, Yu Tea provides a trusted source for the highest-quality, organic Japanese matcha:

• Truly Organic – Grown on certified farms committed to purity and sustainability.

• Calm, Focused Energy – Enjoy mental clarity without the jitters or crash.

• Naturally Detoxifying – Supports gentle, daily cleansing for whole-body wellness.

Exclusive Offer: Enjoy 20% off your first order.

[Shop Now & Save 20%]

The CYP1A2 Gene: Why Your Genetics Change the Game

One of the most important breakthroughs in caffeine research came with the identification of the CYP1A2 gene, which codes for the enzyme responsible for metabolizing caffeine in the liver. This gene comes in several variants, but the most important distinction is between “fast metabolizers” and “slow metabolizers.”

Individuals with the AA variant of CYP1A2 are considered fast metabolizers. They break down caffeine quickly and can experience pronounced performance-enhancing effects with minimal side effects. These athletes typically benefit from standard caffeine protocols—3–6 mg/kg body weight—taken 45–60 minutes before training or racing.

By contrast, individuals with the AC or CC variants are slow metabolizers. They process caffeine more slowly, meaning the stimulant stays in their system longer and can lead to jitteriness, elevated heart rate, gastrointestinal issues, and disrupted sleep. Worse, some studies have shown that caffeine may impair performance in slow metabolizers—particularly in events requiring sustained output over 60–90 minutes.

Genetic testing kits from companies like Athletigen, DNAfit, and InsideTracker now include caffeine metabolism markers, making it easier than ever for athletes to tailor their supplementation strategies based on genetic data.

Timing and Dosing: Science-Backed Strategies for Endurance

Caffeine’s performance-enhancing effects peak roughly 45–60 minutes after ingestion, making this the optimal window to consume it before competition or a hard training session. But the context and intensity of the event influence whether a front-loaded or delayed strategy is more effective.

For longer endurance events (2+ hours), many elite athletes now use a staggered or delayed-release approach. Ingesting 1–2 mg/kg of caffeine in the early stages can help maintain alertness, while reserving an additional 2–3 mg/kg for the second half—often in the form of caffeinated gels or chews—can provide a final boost in focus and output when fatigue sets in.

The total recommended dose is 3–6 mg/kg of body weight, with higher doses offering no additional benefit and increasing the risk of side effects. Importantly, caffeine is not water-soluble above certain concentrations, so taking large doses in capsule form can lead to erratic absorption or stomach upset. Liquids or gels tend to be better tolerated during exercise.

For events under 60 minutes, a single moderate dose taken 30–45 minutes prior is usually sufficient, assuming the athlete is a fast metabolizer and has tested the protocol in training.

Tolerance, Habituation, and Caffeine Cycling

One of the biggest pitfalls athletes face with caffeine is tolerance. Caffeine works by binding to adenosine receptors, and chronic exposure leads the body to upregulate the number of these receptors over time. This means more caffeine is needed to achieve the same effect—and eventually, the ergogenic benefit may be blunted.

To avoid this, many athletes use caffeine cycling protocols, abstaining from caffeine for 7–10 days before an important competition to “reset” their sensitivity. While the evidence is mixed, some research suggests that even 4–5 days of abstinence can increase responsiveness.

Another approach is to periodize caffeine use, reserving higher doses only for key workouts or races while remaining caffeine-free during base training blocks or recovery days. This preserves sensitivity and minimizes disruption to sleep and adrenal function.

Caffeine and the Brain: Beyond Physical Output

In addition to its peripheral effects, caffeine’s impact on mental performance is increasingly recognized as a major component of its ergogenic potential. Studies have shown that caffeine improves reaction time, working memory, and vigilance—particularly during sleep deprivation or mental fatigue.

These effects are especially relevant in ultra-endurance events, multi-day races, and sports requiring split-second decisions under physical strain. Caffeine can delay mental fatigue, improve pacing decisions, and even enhance emotional regulation and motivation late in competition.

Gum and mouth-rinse delivery methods allow for faster uptake via the buccal mucosa, providing a nearly immediate cognitive boost. These forms are ideal in the final stages of a race or in situations where gastrointestinal tolerance is compromised.

Conclusion

Caffeine remains one of the most effective and accessible performance enhancers for endurance athletes—but its benefits are not universal. Understanding your metabolic genotype, dialing in your dosing and timing, and cycling your intake strategically can mean the difference between a personal best and a performance plateau.

Whether you’re a fast metabolizer taking 6 mg/kg 45 minutes before your marathon, or a slow metabolizer using microdoses to manage cognitive fatigue, your caffeine protocol should be as individualized as your training plan.

Train smart. Recover deeply. Dose caffeine intentionally.

Robert